Photo by Mike LaChance

C.J. Wilson and his agent, Bob Garber are seeking $120 million over six years. While Wilson had a great regular season with a 16-7 record, a 2.94 ERA, and a WHIP of 1.19, he showed his true colors during the playoffs. Wilson was 0-3 with a 5.71 ERA and a 1.71 WHIP during the playoffs.

When you look at pitchers who make over $20 million annually such as Cliff Lee, C.C. Sabathia, Roy Halladay, and Johan Santana, it’s hard to put C.J Wilson in that class of elite pitchers. Wilson has only pitched two full seasons as a starter and I’m not convinced that he can match his 2010 and 2011 numbers elsewhere.

The Yankees pitching staff had no problems getting the job done this season, especially in the playoffs. They were fourth in the American League during the regular season posting a 3.73 ERA and first in the MLB with a 3.27 ERA during the playoffs. If I told you at the beginning of the year that the pitching was going to be the Yankees strongest link, you would have laughed in my face.  If there was an award for the “biggest surprise of the year,” Ivan Nova would have taken it hands down. Freddy Garcia exceeded all expectations, Bartolo Colon resurrected from the dead, and C.C. was, well, C.C.

A.J. Burnett is the glaring weakness of the staff and it remains to be seen what Brian Cashman and the Yankees do with him. If the Yankees part-ways with Burnett, there are several pitchers in the free agent market that they could go after for a cheaper price than C.J. Wilson. Two proven starters that would make sense for the Yankees are Roy Oswalt and Mark Buehrle.

If Wilson does cash-in this offseason with a $120 million dollar deal, he will be overpaid by whoever signs him. For the Yankees, they are fortunate enough to have money to ‘overpay’ players, but C.J. Wilson is not worth it.

Photo by Keith Allison

Heading into last year’s spring training the Yankees appeared wounded. New York failed to land their top target Cliff Lee and their rival, the Boston Red Sox, landed two premier offensive players in Adrian Gonzalez and Carl Crawford. Brian Cashman was left bargain hunting to add depth to his starting rotation and plucked Freddy Garcia and Bartolo Colon off the market. Both starters combined for 20 wins and helped New York capture the AL East division crown.

This year the Yankees find themselves in a similar situation. The rotation is anchored by C.C. Sabathia, along with the emerging Ivan Nova , former 18-game winner Phil Hughes and the enigmatic A.J. Burnett. With Hughes and Burnett question marks due to health and inconsistency, and a spot open at the back of the rotation- there’s a need to add depth. The current free agent market doesn’t bode well for the Yankees. C.J. Wilson is the best pitcher on the market, but wants to be paid like an ace without a proven track record. Yu Darvish is the latest Japanese phenom to draw interest in the U.S. Yet, questions surround the small workload Darvish had in Japan since he pitched only once a week and due to the recent failures of Kei Igawa and Daisuke Matsuzaka. Roy Oswalt has a lot of mileage on his right arm and was hurt much of last year with the Phillies. As for Colon, he was injured and ineffective the past four years before his comeback performance with the Yankees. Towards the stretch run Colon appeared fatigued and became ineffective. At 38, his career appears at its twilight stage.

That leaves Garcia and Mark Buehrle as the best remaining options. Buehrle has been a model of consistency for the past eleven years in the White Sox rotation averaging 14 wins per season and nearly 221 innings pitched. Buehrle has also thrown a perfect game and no-hitter in that span. Garcia won twelve games for New York last year and posted a 3.62 ERA, his lowest in eight years. Both provide a different look as soft tossing pitchers that rely on location and movement to get hitters out. New York would benefit from their consistency and veteran presence in the rotation for a run at title number 28 in the Bronx.

Photo by Chris Ptacek

When exactly did Michael Kay decide he needed to come up with his own signature line to “perform” during Yankee broadcasts? Did he feel the need to be more like his old radio counterpart John Sterling- whose self serving style is tough to stomach for many, including myself.

“Put it on the left side!” Kay now exclaims at the conclusion of Yankees victories.

What?

Could Kay have come up with a more contrived phrase? Suddenly, after nearly 20 years of calling Yankee games- this is what he comes up with? It is downright embarassing to hear him utter this ridiculous phrase. To say it sounds forced would be an understatement. I wonder exactly how long he spent trying to come up with such a statement.

Has there ever been a time in Yankees history that it has been more nauseating to listen to a Yankee broadcast? Now more than ever I appreciate the broadcasts Frank Messer, Bill White and Phil Rizzuto put together for so many years. At least Rizzuto’s rants were genuine. There was nothing contrived about their broadcasts.

Kay has been in the business a long time. While I am not a fan of his- even he should be above this manufactured catchphrase. Please Michael Kay, say “See Ya!” to “Put it on the left side!”

Last night, the Yankees road to the postseason may have gotten a bit easier as they enjoyed yet another solid start from rookie Ivan Nova, but manager Joe Girardi’s job may have become more difficult. The pitching rotation, which currently consists of six men, has been the topic of nonstop debate while the Yanks have opened a wide lead on the Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim and Tampa Bay Rays in the Wild Card race. CC Sabathia is the undisputed ace and a Cy Young candidate, while Freddy Garcia (10-7, 3.16 ERA) and Bartolo Colon (8-6, 3.33 ERA) have earned their spots in the postseason rotation with eye-opening career reclamation projects in the Bronx. The 4 through 6 spots on the staff, however, are a mess. $82.5 million man A.J. Burnett, who entered the season as the 2 starter on paper, has been a disaster after a promising first couple months, and now owns a 4.60 ERA and a losing record. Phil Hughes has battled injuries and ineffectiveness while trying to regain his 2010 form which yielded 18 victories, and has a very shaky spot in the rotation after throwing only 38 uninspiring innings thus far to the tune of a 7.11 ERA.

Finally, there is Ivan Nova. The least recognizable name of the bunch just may be the most essential part of the equation in October – if the Yankees realize what they have and decide to keep him around. Nova was unjustly sent to the minor leagues for over a month despite showing some impressive signs in the first half of the season. With his current 11-4 record and 3.85 ERA, one cannot help but wonder whether he could have had a Rookie of the Year-type campaign if he was allowed to pitch an entire year in the majors. Before his six-plus innings of work last night in a 9-3 win over the Angels, Girardi indicated that he has earned his spot in the rotation for the time being. What the manager left unanswered, however, was at whose expense Nova would be staying. In the midst of a tight race with Boston for home field advantage in the American League, the Yankees can simultaneously relax somewhat with the knowledge that their Wild Card lead is very comfortable.

Girardi and GM Brian Cashman can begin to plan for the postseason, which means that if there is a pitcher among their current six starters who is not a part of their playoff plans, they are wasting everyone’s time if they continue to trot that hurler out once a week. In my opinion, A.J. Burnett stands no chance to make the ALDS roster, and his status for the ALCS and World Series is doubtful, as well. His salary should not factor into this equation, just as Jorge Posada’s salary does not matter to the Yanks anymore, and players such as Jason Giambi, Kei Igawa, Javier Vazquez and Kevin Brown did not hold the organization hostage in the past simply because they were well-compensated. If the 2, 3, and 4 spots in the rotation are up for grabs, then Colon, Garcia, Nova and Hughes should spend the next 47 games auditioning, and Burnett should be shut down. Colon and Garcia have postseason experience and have shown steadiness and consistency this year, while Nova has a young, live arm which playoff hitters will be unfamiliar with, giving all three starters an edge over Burnett.  Hughes has been shuffled between the rotation, the bullpen and the minors for far too long, and the Yanks owe him a chance at some type of normalcy if they want him to reach his potential and avoid being “ruined” like Joba Chamberlain may have been.  That leaves Burnett, the 6 starter and the odd man out.  Place him on the DL with some mysterious ailment or relegate him to long relief, just find a way to stop halting everyone else’s progress by extending the rotation by one distracting piece of dead weight. And make the decision today.

Photo by Keith Allison

Does the name Mark Teixeira ring a bell? He plays first base for the New York Yankees. You may not have heard his name much lately because… well, I’m not sure actually.

There is a lot of talk about the red hot Brett Gardner who found himself in the lead-off spot in the lineup Thursday night against the Rays. Curtis Granderson’s name seems to come up a lot also since he is tied for second in homeruns and is having a very solid year.

Yankee pitching is in the conversation. Another starter couldn’t hurt this team, and a middle innings guy wouldn’t be the end of the world either.

Derek Jeter is Derek Jeter. He has over 3,000 hits now and his name pops up side-by-side with Brett Gardner now with all this lineup change stuff.

But what about Mark Teixeira? How does he manage to slip under the radar? He is a high profile performer in the number one media market. And with Alex Rodriguez on the DL, one would think there is more attention on Mark Teixeira. But somehow, I am not hearing much.

Shouldn’t I hear a little more? In the last 11 games (including Thursday night), Teixeira is hitting just .204 with 2 RBI. In those 11 games, the Yankees have lost five games, three of which were by a one run margin.

And when you think about the Yankees needing another pitcher, when C.C. Sabathia continues to pitch gems, those are the games the Yankees need to win. C.C. Sabathia is obviously not the problem with the Yankees starting rotation. Players like Mark Teixeira need to come through.

Even Derek Jeter has received negative attention this year. And if you ever heard anyone talk about Jeter, you would think he was related to Jesus, or that he might even be Jesus living underneath a different name. I mean come on, Jeter and Jesus? You think he could do a better job of coming up with a fake name. We can see right through that nonsense.

If Alex Rodriguez had a stretch like this, there isn’t one soul in the universe that would be unaware of it. Yet somehow, Mark Teixeira has been given some free pass. Nobody is talking about him at all. Is it because he is fourth in the majors in homeruns? I’m not sure.

But the bottom line is this. Mark Teixeira has not been hitting, and whether it is noticed or not, it is the truth. And you can talk about the high payroll, and the 17 games above .500 but that isn’t relevant because it still isn’t good enough. The Yankees are not in first place and that is where they want to be.

So as nice as it is to see Curtis Granderson and Brett Gardner perform at a very high level, the first baseman who is making 22.5 million dollars this year needs to step it up. 25 homeruns is impressive, but a .240 average is not. With Alex Rodriguez out, Mark Teixeira needs to be the big man on campus, and as of late, he has fallen well short of that.

Photo by Keith Allison

Looking back on the happenings of the past few days in Yankee Land, even Alex Rodriguez might turn out to be a less-vilified character than Derek Jeter is within the pinstripe panorama when all is said and done.  To all, that is, except the Yankee fans, who are blinded by the light of their celestial superstar and who would follow their hero into the lion’s den wearing Yankee pot roast suits.

Let’s look at the “holy grail” of all sports memorabilia – THE BALL that went for #3000.   As “right” as everyone thinks the act of Christian Lopez returning the ball to Jeter is, it was absolutely the WRONG thing to do.  Even Lopez will realize that in time. Unfortunately, he looks like a good, honest kid who didn’t deserve to be dragged into this mess – and now he may be socked with a five-figure tax bill for his decency and from the Yankees’ lovely parting gifts. Things are much different today than in 1961 when Sal Durante caught Roger Maris’ 61st HR ball.  Lopez should have kept the ball and sold it – paid off his famous student loan and more.  What’s more, Jeter (who looked ridiculous while wearing a t-shirt and cap with his own picture on it) seemed pretty nonplussed when he got the ball back.  He said something to the effect that the ball looked and felt like all the other baseballs he’d handled.  Ideally, Jeter should send the ball to Cooperstown where the game’s historical mementos belong.

How about “Captain Courageous” passing on the All-Star Game?  He’s gone through so much – the half-season, the injury, the rehabbing in Tampa, the stress of the road to 3,000.  What Maris went through in ‘61 when he was chasing the ghost of the most beloved Yankee and an American legend, THAT was stress.  Jeter just passed a very significant baseball milestone and he should be at the Mid-Summer Classic in Arizona so the fans can see him – whether he plays or not.

Perhaps Jeter will spend the break signing memorabilia so he can further cash-in.  I’m holding out for the plastic bags with the “DJ3K” logo filled with Yankee Stadium air from last Saturday.  It’s fully authenticated, of course.  There are “DJ3K” balls, bats, photos – a thousand poses from every conceivable (some inconceivable, as well) angle, bases, ticket stubs, jerseys, caps, cleats, socks, dirt – anything tangible!  And if “Captain Intangible” could find a way to sign something intangible, he would, and they’d sell that, too!

Granted, Jeter is a great ballplayer and he’s accomplished so much on the ball field.  And cashing in has become as American as baseball itself.  He might even be the “face” of the game right now.   (Which is why he should be at the All-Star Game.)   Unfortunately, Jeter’s been “deified” by blind faith.  He’s been turned into this larger-than-life icon by pinstriped hands & fans.  We don’t know how the book on Derek Jeter will end.  Enjoy the present and revel in watching it play out.  Allow history to forge the legacy of a great player.

Finish this sentence: The older Derek Jeter gets, the more ________________________

The New York Yankees are in first place in the month of June. This shows us two things; they are a solid baseball team and they know what it takes to win. Still, this Yankee team is far from complete. They are going to need to make a big splash come the trade deadline if they want to add championship number twenty-eight.

One suprise has been the productivity of the starting pitching.  Bartolo Colon is pitching like he did when he won the Cy Young award, and Freddy Garcia has been consistently getting guys out. I have faith in Colon to keep it up- but what happens if he doesn’t? Ivan Nova has looked great at times and terrible other times. How can you rely on him when he has been incredibly inconsistent? You have potential question marks at your #4 and #5 spots in the rotation. This rotation is far from complete, and don’t be banking on Phil Hughes returning and making a significant impact if he ever comes back.

In order for the Yankees to have a complete rotation, they need an ace to go along with Sabathia, or at least a solid #2 pitcher. The pitcher the Yankees should be targeting is Felix Hernandez. With the talents the Yankees have in their farm system, in the words of the Godfather… lets just say they could make an offer they can’t refuse.

Of course there are other pitchers the Yankees coul target. Fransisco Liriano is a name that has been talked about for months. Although Liriano has not been that effective this year other than his no hitter earlier this season, he could be a solid number #2 or #3 for the Yankees- considering AJ Burnett has had a fantastic turnaround season thus far. They could also look at guys like Ryan Dempster, Mike Pelfrey, and Derek Lowe; all guys the Yankees could use in order to complete a rotation that is still not 100% completed.

The next part of the Yankees that is still not complete is the lineup. WHAT?! Yes, the Yankees lineup is still not complete as of right now. They obviously do not need another star in the lineup, but they do need role players. Andruw Jones has been good so far, but can you trust him to pinch hit in late September?

The Yankees need some help out their in the outfield. We have seen how bad Nick Swisher and Brett Gardner can be at the plate, and the Yankees also need some help on the bench so they do not have A.J Burnett pinch running in a baseball game. Look at a guy like Jonny Gomes. He hit 18 HR and 86 RBI last season. In a place like Cincinatti, it should not be hard to pry Gomes away. Also look at a guy like Juan Pierre. While he may be 33 now, he still has his wheels. His 68 steals were tops in the AL last season. He also should not be hard to get from the White Sox for a few prospects. How about a trade that brings Pierre and Mark Buehrle? Do not put it past Brian Cashman.

The bullpen is one area that I think the Yankees are complete in. Soriano has been a major bust so far, but I believe he will get back to pitching the way he can.  Robertson has been fantastic this season, and Mariano Rivera is, well- Mariano Rivera. If there is one area the Yankees can fix in their pen, it is getting a better lefty specialist. I simply don’t trust Boone Logan in any big spot, and the way Girardi mixes and matches with right handers and left handers- they could use a shut down left handed specialist

The Yankees and their fans should be very pleased with the fact that they are in first place with the trade deadline almost a month away. The Yankees are a solid baseball team and a contender- no doubt about it. However, if the Yankees want to raise another banner next April, they will have to realize this team is good- but yet not complete.

Photo by Keith Allison

When a conversation about Derek Jeter begins, it almost always goes in the same direction. There is no debate about the greatness that is Derek Jeter. Whether it be winning Rookie of the Year, being an All-Star in almost every season, winning the All-Star game MVP, and the World Series MVP, it is not hard to find Derek Jeter’s accomplishments. Any Yankee or baseball fan in general can name them. Add Silver Slugger Awards and Gold Glove Awards and there is no doubt that Derek Jeter is a first ballot Hall of Famer.

We also know that at some point in the next couple of weeks, Derek Jeter will reach the 3,000 hit plateau to add to his long list of achievements. Fans, and just humans in general love milestones and love big numbers. They love seeing their favorite players in the record books.

The ultimate goal of all fans though, is winning championships. Granted, this can vary based on the team one roots for. Pirates fans I’m sure are not expecting a World Series title this year. Teams like that would just love to see a playoff appearance at the least. Teams like that, and fans of those teams, fall in love with their young stars and hope they will be good for the “team’s future.”

However, over the last decade and a half the Yankees never had the “hope for the team’s future.” The Yankees were always a team thinking about the now. They are the team that wants to win the World Series THIS year. They are not looking to build for future years. Obviously if they can build and win now at the same time, that is a plus. Robinson Cano is of course that kind of player, and Derek Jeter is/was as well.

So what’s my point? The point is this. If you were to ask a Yankee fan what he or she would like to see from the Yankees this year, I think the answer would be the same amongst everyone. “I want the Yankees to win the World Series.” Sure they also want to see Derek Jeter reach 3,00o hits. They probably also want to see Alex Rodriguez hit 630 homeruns. But fans never answer the question of what they want to see their team do with a list of milestones. Fans list the goals they want for the team as a whole.

“I want Team X to win this many games.”

“I want Team X to get to the playoffs.”

“I want Team X to win the World Series.”

THOSE are the answers. The individual milestones are just a bonus. Of course though the individual milestones are very exciting, and sometimes can overshadow team goals.

Enter Derek Jeter in 2011. Entering Friday night’s game against the Angels, Derek Jeter was batting .264 with just a pair of homeruns, and 16 RBI. Yankee and baseball fans alike are also aware that Derek Jeter certainly had a down year last year finishing with a .270 batting average, the worst of his career. The talk about his fielding never goes away either. I am just going to add the fact that in innings 4-9 this year, Jeter has a .188 batting average. He is hitting .337 in innings 1-3. But as the games go on, and hits become more pertinent, he is not getting hits.

Again, I do not want to take away from the great career of Derek Jeter. He will forever be known as one of the top players to ever play the game. But we must remember the “NOW.” Yankee fans every year want their team to win the World Series. And as great as the 3,000 hit milestone will be for the Yankees, their fans, and of course Derek Jeter, it is important that we don’t let it overshadow what is actually happening.

We must ask: Is Derek Jeter, right now, in a position to put the Yankees back on top as champions of baseball? As recently as 2009, the answer was yes. But is that still the answer in 2011?

One of the many wonderful things about Bill Gallo’s work was his uncanny ability to blend the worlds and reach far beyond the field-of-play. Gallo was always able to capture the realness of humanity (on and off the field), visually tap into our emotions, color our senses, and depict the true heart of what it means to be a fan.

The black-and-white world lost a whole lot of color today. RIP.

One of the more well-known proverbs warns the individual that they must lie in the bed they’ve made for themselves. For example, those who sleep around while they’re married tend to end up alone once both parties figure out what they’re up to. In general, people have to take both the good and the bad consequences that come with their actions.

Someone needs to refresh Brian Cashman on the existence of this proverb. On Saturday, Cashman criticized the Mets’ treatment of new Yankee Pedro Feliciano, who is currently on the disabled list with a shoulder injury. Cashman used the word “abused” to describe his use by the Mets, who trotted him out to the mound 266 times in the past three years, including 92 games last season.

Cashman has a right to be upset that his $8 million investment hasn’t earned a cent of that money in a regular-season game yet, and may not for at least a month. But his finger-pointing isn’t helping matters. The statement was a deflection tactic, an attempt to use the much-maligned Mets management to make people forget that the Yankees took a risk when they signed the 34-year-old lefty. It’s a risk the Yankees knew they were taking, and it’s one they’ll have to take responsibility for.

One of the general rules about pitchers in major league baseball (and at any level) is that the more they throw, the more susceptible to injury they become. Denny McLain’s workload during his 31-win MVP season of 1968 ended up sapping him of his ability to pitch by 1972. Mike Marshall, who set appearance records in 1973 and 1974 and threw nearly 400 innings out of the bullpen in those two seasons, dealt with injuries that prevented him from pitching a full season again until 1979; he was out of baseball two years later. Part of Doc Gooden’s downfall was credited to the 644.2 innings he pitched in his first three seasons. Every now and then, you’ll get a Nolan Ryan or a Greg Maddux, who can withstand years of pitching 200+ innings without suffering arm problems. But for every Ryan, there’s an Andy Messersmith, and for every Maddux, there’s a Mark Prior, a pitcher with tremendous talent who has it sapped from him due to arm problems.

Feliciano may not have thrown over 300 innings in a season, like McLain did, but he approached Mike Marshall-like numbers in terms of appearances. In fact, he eclipsed them; his 266 appearances over the last three years were a major league record. “Perpetual” Pedro, as he was known to Mets fans, would frequently get into every game of a three or four-game set, particularly if the opposing team was from Philadelphia. He was the linchpin of the team’s bullpen. He was Jerry Manuel’s most consistent performer. And he wanted the workload that he got, if you believe Dan Warthen’s response to Cashman’s comments yesterday. There was no sense of outrage from any party while Feliciano was wearing orange and blue.

One of Sandy Alderson’s biggest decisions this off-season was deciding whether to bring back Feliciano, particularly at the $4 million per year he was expected to fetch on the open market. His service to the Mets over the previous three seasons was unquestionably important to the team’s success, but leftover thoughts of the “Moneyball” philosophy on left-handed specialists (specifically, the over-rating of lefty-lefty/righty-righty matchups), as well as concerns over Feliciano’s workload, caused the Mets to let him go. The Yankees swooped in and gave him that two-year, $8 million contract, presumably after considering at least the latter concern, which makes Cashman’s comments on Saturday stranger at this point.

The one thing that comes to mind is that Cashman never wanted Feliciano on the Yankees to begin with. If you remember, when the Yankees gave Rafael Soriano a big contract to be the team’s setup man this off-season, Cashman distanced himself from the signing, saying it came from executives above his head in the organization. It’s possible that Cashman didn’t want to spend that type of money on Feliciano, either, and that he’s lashing out at his own organization with his comments. That seems to be the most logical explanation, at least.

It certainly doesn’t make sense to lash out at the Mets months after bringing the lefty specialist in, though. Everyone knew that the Mets used Feliciano at a record pace in the last three years. It’s not a stretch to imagine that he would suffer from arm problems at any point of the two-year deal he signed. It’s a shame that it happened in the inaugural moments of the contract, but that’s the risk the Yankees took.

Gerald R. Johnson once said that “no man was ever endowed with a right without being at the same time saddled with a responsibility”. Cashman had the right to offer Feliciano the contract he did. He can’t try to deflect the responsibility now that he took that risk.

He made his bed. Now he has to lie in it.